Now an Adobe Platinum Partner. Click here to learn more.


Subscription Commerce: A Powerful Strategy for Sustainable Growth in Ecommerce

By: Jackson Cuneo
< Back to resources

In today’s competitive ecommerce landscape, businesses are constantly seeking new ways to engage customers, build loyalty, and drive sustained growth. Subscription commerce has emerged as a game-changer and powerful tool for achieving these goals, reshaping how consumers interact with brands and products.

But what’s behind the growth of subscription-based ecommerce? Understand the basics and the broad appeal of subscription commerce with this guide and learn what you need to overcome the most common challenges facing both new and fast-expanding subscription brands.

What is Subscription Commerce and Why is it Growing?

Subscription commerce, at its core, is a business model where customers pay a recurring fee at regular intervals to access a product or service. This model contrasts with traditional one-time purchase models, typically offering a more personalized and convenient experience for customers.

Rather than making one-time purchases, customers subscribe to receive products or services at predetermined intervals, often at a discounted rate. This arrangement can support a win-win situation: businesses enjoy predictable recurring revenue and improved customer lifetime value, while customers benefit from convenience, personalization, and exclusive member benefits.

At least in part as a result of this shared convenience, the popularity of subscription commerce is soaring. According to one estimate, the subscription commerce market may reach $1.5 trillion in value by 2025, up from “just” $650 billion in 2020.[1] This rapid growth can be attributed to several factors:

  • Convenience and ease of access: Customers appreciate the convenience of receiving regular deliveries without needing to repurchase items individually.
  • Personalization and curated experiences: Subscription boxes cater to specific interests and preferences, offering a more personalized shopping experience.
  • Exclusive benefits and member offers: Subscribers often receive exclusive discounts, early access to new products, and other perks, fostering a sense of community and loyalty.
  • Reduced waste and sustainability: Subscription models may encourage responsible consumption by providing products in the right quantities and reducing packaging waste.

Different Types of Subscription Commerce Models

Subscription commerce isn’t just convenient for consumers. The flexibility of subscription commerce also extends to businesses, who by tailoring their offerings to a subscription model can deliver relevant products or services to specific target audiences. Businesses may deliver subscriptions in one or more of these popular types of subscription-based models:

  • Curation subscriptions: These offer a box of curated products delivered at regular intervals, often themed around a specific niche such as beauty, fashion, or food. Popular examples include Birchbox and HelloFresh.
  • Replenishment subscriptions: These focus on delivering essential, consumable products like razors, coffee, or pet supplies before they run out, ensuring customers never experience stockouts. Success stories in this realm include Dollar Shave Club and Quip.
  • Membership or access subscriptions: These offer access to exclusive content, services, or discounts in exchange for a monthly or annual fee. Examples include Amazon Prime and Netflix, as well as Substack and the monetization platform Patreon.
  • Digital subscriptions: These provide access to digital content such as music, streaming services, or online courses for a recurring fee. Examples include Spotify and Masterclass.
  • Software as a service (SaaS): A prevalent model in the tech industry, SaaS offers software and applications to customers on a subscription basis, eliminating the need for physical copies or licenses. Well-known SaaS brands include Slack, Zoom, Salesforce, and Google Workspace.

Common Challenges for Subscription Commerce Brands

The allure and opportunity of subscription commerce for many brands can’t be denied, but all the growth in the market doesn’t mean that success comes easy. Brands embracing subscription-based ecommerce models must navigate a unique set of challenges to maintain customer engagement, streamline operations and service delivery, and ensure profitability.

Customer Churn

The Challenge: Customer retention is important to all businesses, but especially to those operating on a subscription model. Customer churn in subscription commerce, where customers discontinue their subscriptions, poses a significant challenge. This churn can be voluntary, stemming from customer dissatisfaction or changes in needs, or involuntary, often a result of back-end issues such as failed payments. Involuntary churn is particularly concerning as it occurs despite the customer’s intention to continue the service. These failures can be due to expired credit cards, insufficient funds, or technical glitches in the payment system.

Solutions and Strategies: To reduce voluntary churn, businesses should focus on enhancing customer satisfaction through personalized experiences and consistent quality improvements. To combat involuntary churn, it’s crucial to implement an efficient payment processing system that’s backed by an extensive acquiring network. Regular updates and reminders to customers about expiring payment methods, along with seamless payment retry and recovery mechanisms, can significantly reduce involuntary churn. Employing smart payment solutions that automatically update credit card information can also be effective. Moreover, analyzing churn data helps in identifying the primary causes and allows for targeted strategies to address them.

Upselling and Expansion

The Challenge: Successfully upselling or cross-selling to existing subscribers is another hurdle. It requires understanding customer needs and preferences, and then effectively communicating the value of higher-tiered or additional services. Without a nuanced approach, attempts at upselling can seem pushy and might lead to customer dissatisfaction.

Solutions and Strategies: Effective upselling begins with a deep understanding of customer behavior and preferences, often gleaned from data analytics. Personalized offers, based on customer usage patterns and preferences, can be more effective. Timing these offers strategically—such as after a positive customer service interaction or upon the release of new features—can also increase their acceptance.

Logistics Concerns

The Challenge: Managing the logistics of a subscription model, especially for physical goods, is complex. It involves ensuring timely deliveries, managing inventory levels, and handling returns or exchanges. Inefficient logistics can lead to customer dissatisfaction and increased operational costs.

Solutions and Strategies: Streamlining logistics requires a robust supply chain and inventory management system. Implementing technology solutions for real-time tracking and inventory forecasting can greatly enhance efficiency. Additionally, partnering with reliable logistics providers with global experience can ensure timely and accurate deliveries, enhancing customer satisfaction no matter where they subscribe from.

Sophisticated Pricing and Tiering

The Challenge: Developing a pricing strategy for a subscription service can be daunting. The challenge lies in creating tiered pricing models that are attractive to a wide range of customers while also maintaining profitability. The complexity and challenge of striking the right balance between offering value and driving growth is only compounded when operating in multiple global markets with varying consumer preferences and price sensitivities.

Solutions and Strategies: Successful pricing strategies often involve market research to understand what customers value and are willing to pay for. Dynamic pricing models, which can be adjusted based on market response and customer feedback, can also be effective. Offering a range of pricing tiers with clearly differentiated value propositions ensures that there is an option for different customer segments.

Ready to unlock the potential of subscription commerce?

Digital River stands at the forefront of enabling businesses to maximize the benefits of subscription commerce while navigating its complexities:

  • Optimized Billing: Our sophisticated solutions streamline the billing process, minimizing payment declines and ensuring a seamless experience for both businesses and customers.
  • Fraud Mitigation: We employ advanced security measures to protect against fraud and, as merchant of record, assume liability for all transactions processed along with any customer data collected on your behalf.
  • Simplifying Regulatory Complexity: Our expertise in global regulations ensures compliance across different markets, reducing legal and operational risks.
  • Reconciling Recurring Sales Globally: We specialize in managing global sales, accommodating various currencies, preferred payment methods, and tax regulations, helping you drive fast global expansion with localized experiences.

By partnering with Digital River, businesses can harness the full potential of subscription commerce, transcending traditional boundaries and elevating their customer relationships to new heights.

Learn more about our leading digital sales and subscription management solutions, including MyCommerce, a turnkey hosted checkout purpose-built for digital and SaaS brands, and contact us today.